1. Smalley believes that nanobots are potentially dangerous because they could reproduce uncontrollably. He also thinks they are impossible due to two issues which he calls “fat fingers” and “sticky fingers”. However Drexler does not think nanobots could be this dangerous and does not believe they are impossible to make.
2. There are a few things at stake in this argument. First both of these men want to gain followers of their and opinions and maintain the ones they have. Secondly neither Smalley nor Drexler want to be proved wrong and look like they are not as knowledgeable on nanobots.
3. One strategy used by Smalley and Drexler is they both acknowledge the areas they agree upon. This makes them look more creditable. They both also use many specific facts and studies. Smalley particularly does this when he uses actual numbers when explaining how fast the nanobots could reproduce.
4. Smalley and Drexler both directly attack the others point. They explain what is wrong with the other’s reasoning and why theirs is right. For this particular topic it is better that they made counterarguments instead of refutation.
5. One way Smalley and Drexler build there ethos is they both acknowledge the areas they agree upon. This makes them look more creditable. They both also use many specific facts and studies. Smalley particularly does this when he uses actual numbers when explaining how fast the nanobots could reproduce.
6. Smalley use a fallacy by saying “I see you have now walked out of the room where I had led you to talk about real chemistry…” This is a fallacy because Smalley does not even continue to prove how Drexler is not talk about “real chemistry”. However, Drexler also used a fallacy by stating “Endorsing calls for an independent scientific review of molecular manufacturing concepts would be constructive.” This statement was irrelevant to proving his point and was not backed up by any reasoning.
7. I think Smalley’s side was more convincing because his points and arguments were clearer. Drexler never really said how he knew the nanobots would not reproduce infinitely but just how Smalley was only trying to scare the public.